Amy tan's two kinds and best quality depict a struggling and often stressful relationship between a defiant daughter and an overbearing mother june mei and her mother suyuan engage in a destructive battle between what is possible and what is realistic june, although headstrong, seeks her. After june's decision to not take piano seriously and her mishap at the talent show, suyuan finds her watching tv instead of practicing suyuan tells her to turn the tv off but june refuses to do so, causing tension between the two. Suyuan: [takes off necklace she is wearing and gives it to june] june, since your baby time, i wear this next to my heart now, you wear next to yours now, you wear next to yours it will help you know. June and suyuan's relationship is punctuated by conflict in two kinds suyuan pushes june to the breaking point by forcing her to play piano and june brings up a subject - the death of suyuan's twin daughters - that shocks and emotionally wounds suyuan. Characteristics of each mother/daughter relationship relate to the four main themes of the novel suyuan, and twin daughters during the sino june replaces.
Suyuan founded the joy luck club, and china (the east) is where the mothers begin and where the daughters' identities also begin june/jing-mei completes her. The relationship between a mother and her daughter are often very complicated and conflicting also the mind set of suyuan and june is because there is a. The joy luck club student copy what is the overall feeling of june's relationship with her mother based on the memories what is suyuan telling june when she. The jade pendant given to jing-mei june by her mother suyuan woo is symbolic for the relationship june has with her mother before and after suyuan's death in the story narrated by june entitled best quality, she says, my mother gave me my life's importance, a jade pendant on a gold chain (197.
The mother-daughter relationship between suyuan woo and jing-mei is one that is tainted with resentment jing-mei feels this way towards her mother because of suyuan's continual attempts of transforming her daughter from a typical chinese-american child into a prodigy. Amy tan's two kinds and best quality depict a struggling and often stressful relationship between a defiant daughter and an overbearing mother june mei and her mother suyuan engage in a destructive battle between what is possible and what is reali. The mother/ daughter conflict within the joy luck club by amy tan (image courtesy of google images) the character conflict pattern that i chose to follow was that of suyuan woo and her daughter jing- mei woo. The joy luck club quotes -suyuan ― amy tan , relationship 52 likes like if she doesn't speak, she is making a choice if she doesn't try, she can. The novel centered most particularly on the relationship between suyuan woo and jing-mei june woo, whose antagonistic treatment against each other was the result of misperceptions and misunderstandings from the different cultures they had known and grew up with.
The way that their relationship develops, and the conflicts june and suyuan face, reveal some of the themes that amy tan intends for the readers to learn these themes concern such topics as finding our life's importance, making choices, and understanding ourselves and our families. When the novel opens, a mother, suyuan woo, has died of a cerebral aneurysm, and her husband has asked their thirty-six-year-old daughter, jing-mei (june), to assume her mother's role and take her seat at the next meeting of the joy luck club. Characterization jing-mei (june) woo: she is the daughter of suyuan and canning woo jing-mei and her mother always had a troubled relationship when her mother dies. June's mother, suyuan woo, has died recently her father has asked her to take over her mother's corner of the mah jong table in the joy luck club her father has asked her to take over her mother's corner of the mah jong table in the joy luck club.
For example, when suyuan woo pushed her daughter june to be a pianist, suyuan simply wanted june to excel at something and to go somewhere suyuan invited all of her friends from the joy luck club to june's piano recital, and june failed miserably. Due to distressed communicational nets, june and suyuan maintain a staggering relationship, which ultimately ends in suyuan's poignant acceptance of her daughter's individuality and cultural evolution. Suyuan and june's character have a mother-daughter relationship confused with scattered conflict however, it will ultimately be composed of deep love and commitment for one another most of the conflicts that suyuan and june face are based on misunderstandings and negligence concerning each others opinions. The novel set up with a story of the exodus of suyuan woo, jing-mei's mother, and the groundwork of the joy luck club the members include three other chinese immigrant families the four mothers have daughters born in america, who have strong misunderstanding to china. In the relationship between suyuan and her daughter june, it is one with silence and secrecy june who was very stubborn and would not accept her mothers chinese heritage it is hard to mix one heritage with another, since you live in a country far different from where junes mother had lived.
Suyuan woo was the mother of jing-mei june woo, and the founder of the joy luck club, a group of women who come together once weekly to play mahjong she started the club in china, in the early days of her first marriage. Mother daughter relations in the joy luck club: jing-mei and suyuan woo through out the collection of vignettes amy tan, the author of the joy luck club, shows us some things that are uniquely chinese but still universal at the same time one way is that the relationship is universal is the way that. June's relationship with her mother in joy luck club essay pages 2 words 1,112 view full essay more essays like this: amy tan, the joy luck club, dominant theme. Thus, in two kinds and best quality there is a healing process with understanding but not before a cultural conflict can plague the relationship finally, the communicational and cultural barrier between mother and daughter almost breaks, broadening june's understanding of her life's importance and suyuan's hopes.
The joy luck club well written and riveting, amy tan's fictional masterpiece the joy luck club bypasses the traditional straight narrative style and. Suyuan, the mother of june, and june herself had a complex relationship they seem to have a hard time communicating with each other at times i was responsible, no matter who did it (16.
In addition to the relationship between suyuan and june, the novel examines three other mother-daughter relationships the mothers often boast about their daughters' successes to others but scold their daughters in private for having weaknesses, creating an emotional disconnection between the mother-daughter pairs.